What Makes Some Franchises Succeed While Others Struggle? Here Are 5 Market Factors You Should Not Ignore

by | Apr 10, 2025

A franchise that works in one city can fail in another. The key is demand, competition, and location-specific trends.

Before you commit, ask yourself:

  • Are enough people looking for this product or service?
  • Can they afford to pay for it?
  • Is the market growing or shrinking?
  • How much competition already exists?

Skipping this step means walking into an uphill battle.

Demographics Shape Business Success

You’re not selling to a spreadsheet. You’re selling to people. If the right people aren’t in your area, the business won’t work.

Example: Running Culture and Fitness Trends

  • Running has exploded among millennials and Gen Zs. Cities with parks, running trails, and active communities create strong demand for athletic gear, smoothie bars, and recovery centers.
  • A high-end running shoe store will do well where people train for marathons. It won’t do much in a town where running isn’t part of the culture.

Tangible Tip: Check local event calendars. Look for marathons, cycling races, or fitness expos. If they don’t exist, demand might be weak.

Example: Remote Work and Changing Buying Habits

  • Work-from-home setups have changed where people spend money.
  • Office district lunch spots are struggling. Suburban cafes and coworking spaces are booming.
  • A franchise that relies on office workers will struggle if most companies in the area have gone remote.

Tangible Tip: Check office occupancy rates. A half-empty downtown means businesses relying on foot traffic will suffer.

How to Know if a Market Has Potential

1. Demand: Are People Looking for This Business?

Example: A high-end pet grooming business thrives in neighborhoods where people treat pets like family. It won’t work in a market where owners choose basic services over premium care.

Tangible Tip: Search for similar businesses in your area. Read customer reviews. Are people complaining about wait times or poor service? That’s a gap you can fill.

2. Competition: Is the Market Already Too Crowded?

Example: A burger franchise opening near five other burger chains will fight an uphill battle. A Mexican fast-casual restaurant in the same area might dominate because there’s no strong competition.

Tangible Tip: Visit competitors at different times of the day. Are they packed, or are they empty? A strong competitor with loyal customers makes it harder to break in.

3. Location: Will Customers Actually Come?

Example: A luxury hair salon in a busy shopping district attracts walk-in customers. A high-end bakery in a low-traffic location might struggle, no matter how good it is.

Tangible Tip: Spend a full day at potential locations. Count how many people walk by, what they do, and if they fit your target customer.

4. Consumer Spending Power: Can They Afford This Business?

Example: A boutique fitness studio charging premium rates will fail in a neighborhood where people prioritize budget-friendly gyms. It will thrive in a high-income area where people expect high-end services.

Tangible Tip: Look up median income levels in your area. If your business depends on premium pricing, the local economy has to support it.

5. Industry Growth: Is This Business Expanding or Dying?

Example: Home services like plumbing, electrical work, and restoration are growing as homes age and people invest in renovations. Video rental stores were once everywhere. Now they don’t exist.

Tangible Tip: Read industry reports. See what’s growing and what’s fading before investing.

Key Terms Every Franchisee Needs to Know

Market Share – How much of the total industry revenue a brand captures. A franchise with shrinking market share may be losing relevance.

Break-even Point – The moment revenue covers expenses. A franchise with high costs and slow customer growth will take longer to become profitable.

Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) – The total amount a customer spends over time. Subscription-based businesses usually have higher CLV than one-time purchase models.

Barriers to Entry – The difficulty level for competitors to enter the market. If it’s too easy to start a similar business, expect constant price competition.

How to Choose a Franchise That Matches Your Market

Check local demographics. Make sure the customer base exists.
Analyze competition. Too many similar businesses will make it harder to gain traction.
Look at customer spending habits. Are people willing to pay for what you’re selling?
Evaluate location feasibility. If customers don’t pass by regularly, sales will suffer.
Follow industry trends. Growing industries have more long-term potential.

Franchise success doesn’t come from choosing the biggest brand. It comes from selecting a business that fits the right market.

Before you invest, check if the demand exists.

Unsure if your market is the right fit? Book a free introductory call to assess your franchise options and make an informed decision.